Every great mystery show needs a guy who shows up, says something ominously vague about ancient cosmic horrors, and makes the internet immediately start building a murder board. On the Lanterns HBO Show, that guy is Antaan, played by veteran “oh hey, it’s that guy” character actor Paul Ben-Victor.
And DC fans have collectively decided, with the confidence of a group chat that’s had too much coffee, that Antaan is not just some rando extraterrestrial truth-seeker. He is almost certainly Atrocitus, the ring-slinging, blood-oath-swearing, universally furious founder of the Red Lantern Corps, wearing a very thin disguise and an even thinner alias. Let’s break down why the Lanterns HBO Show may have been hiding one of DC’s angriest villains in plain sight this entire time.
Who Is Antaan, According To The Lanterns HBO Show Itself?
When Paul Ben-Victor’s casting was first announced, Deadline described his character as an extraterrestrial devoted to exposing the truth and exacting vengeance against those who wronged his people — consumed, and this is the important part, by “a deep and unrelenting hatred for the law,” determined to deliver justice on his own terms. That is an extremely specific character description for someone supposedly invented from scratch.
Nerdist noticed the same thing almost immediately, pointing out that the Green Lantern comics simply don’t have a character named Antaan, and that the description reads suspiciously like a paraphrase of one very particular red-skinned grudge-holder.
Trailers for the Lanterns HBO Show have only fed the theory. In the Comic-Con footage covered by Space.com, Antaan is the one delivering the show’s biggest lore-dump line yet, warning that Manhunters are “the most dangerous beings to ever exist in the galaxy” and that they can take the form of any species.
Bleeding Cool’s breakdown of the same teaser noted Antaan explaining that the Manhunters have existed for ages and can imitate virtually any living thing — dialogue delivered with the kind of weary, seen-it-all rage that suggests personal experience, not academic interest. TV Guide’s own rundown of the Lanterns HBO Show confirms the Manhunters — Jack Kirby’s shapeshifting android peacekeepers — are the season’s driving threat, having gone rogue at some point and slaughtered nearly an entire sector’s population.
If you know your Green Lantern comics even a little, alarm bells should be going off right about now.
A Very Quick, Very Bloody History Of Atrocitus
For anyone who needs the lore refresher: in the comics, Atrocitus (birth name Atros) was a member of a peaceful species called the Five Inversions living in Sector 666, until the Guardians of the Universe ordered the Manhunters — their original robotic police force, long before the Green Lantern Corps existed — to wipe out his entire sector after deeming its inhabitants a threat.
Atros survived, but only after watching the Manhunters slaughter his wife, his children, and effectively his whole world. He spent the following millennia consumed by grief and fury, eventually forging the first Red Lantern power battery out of pure rage, founding the Red Lantern Corps, and swearing a blood oath against the Guardians and everyone who ever served them — including, notably, Green Lanterns.
It’s an origin story that runs entirely on hatred for the law, vengeance against those who wronged his people, and a Manhunter-shaped hole in his heart. Sound familiar?
Connecting The Dots: Why The Lanterns HBO Show’s Antaan Fits Atrocitus Like A Glove
Line them up side by side and the coincidences stop feeling like coincidences. Antaan’s official description matches Atrocitus’s motivations almost word for word: exposing the truth, exacting vengeance, hatred for the law, justice on his own terms. The Lanterns HBO Show trailers have positioned Antaan as the resident expert on the Manhunters specifically — not Sinestro, not Guy Gardner, not anyone actually in the Green Lantern Corps, but this one mysterious alien who seems to know exactly how dangerous, ancient, and shapeshifty they are.
That’s not the kind of intel you casually pick up; that’s the kind of intel you get from personally watching them exterminate your species. JoBlo’s report on the casting drew the same line, noting that fans immediately connected Antaan to Atrocitus specifically because of his tragic backstory involving the death of his family “as well as nearly every living being in his sector” during a Manhunter rampage — which is, word for word, the plot of Sector 666.
Even the show’s insistence on keeping Antaan an “original character” reads a little too convenient. Deadline’s original report never used the word Atrocitus once, but the internet’s comment section did the work for them — one Deadline reader replied to the casting news with “Sounds more like Atrocitus.
Wonder if this is a ‘red’ herring,” which might be the single most DC-fan sentence ever typed into a comments box. Batman News and TV Guide’s cast rundowns for the Lanterns HBO Show both keep Antaan filed under vague “extraterrestrial investigator” duties, which, again, is exactly how you’d describe a man secretly hunting down the robots that murdered his family, if you didn’t want to spoil that he’s about to build a battery out of pure hatred and start handing out red rings.
What This Would Mean For The Rest Of The Lanterns HBO Show
If the Lanterns HBO Show is indeed setting up Antaan as a soon-to-be-revealed Atrocitus, that’s a genuinely smart long-game move for a series billing itself as a “True Detective”-style murder mystery, per multiple outlets covering the show’s tone. Instead of introducing the Red Lantern Corps’ founder with a cosmic space battle and a five-minute flashback, the show gets to plant him as a grounded, morally ambiguous background character quietly working his own investigation alongside Hal Jordan and John Stewart’s murder case — before the rug gets pulled and audiences realize the guy giving exposition about ancient killer robots has been the galaxy’s angriest true-crime obsessive the entire time.
It would also explain why the murders Hal and John are investigating in rural Nebraska involve aliens being killed by shapeshifters, per TV Guide’s trailer breakdown — because if Antaan really is Atrocitus, he’s not just an interested bystander to this mystery. He may be the one who’s been hunting the Manhunters responsible, decades or centuries in the making, and just found them again in the middle of nowhere, USA.
Of course, nothing here is confirmed. DC Studios and HBO have not officially acknowledged the Atrocitus theory, and the Lanterns HBO Show has stuck rigidly to calling Antaan an original character in every cast list published so far. But between the near-identical character description, the Manhunter-massacre backstory, and Antaan’s suspiciously specific expertise on the very monsters that made Atrocitus who he is, this is about as close to a smoking gun as trailer-analysis speculation gets.
The Bottom Line
Whether Antaan turns out to be a red herring or, well, a Red Lantern, the Lanterns HBO Show has done a remarkable job of hiding a potential DC mythology bomb inside a guy who mostly shows up to deliver ominous one-liners about ancient robot murderers. The series premieres August 16 on HBO and HBO Max, and if Paul Ben-Victor’s eyes start glowing red at any point this season, nobody who’s been paying attention should act surprised.
Keep coming back to ScreenTrak for the latest in the world of entertainment!
Sources referenced: Deadline — original casting report · Nerdist · JoBlo · Collider · Batman News · SoapCentral · DC Universe Wiki (Fandom) · Space.com · Bleeding Cool · Variety · TV Guide · MEAWW · GamesRadar+ · El-Balad
