If the You Can See Everything first reactions are anything to go by, Nathan Fielder has once again found a way to make an entire industry squirm, gasp, and immediately reach for their phones.
The Elizabeth Holmes documentary — co-directed with Lance Oppenheim and dropped on an unsuspecting Telluride crowd as a “secret screening” — has become the most talked-about movie of the fall, and the You Can See Everything first reactions rolling in from critics, festival-goers, and the chronically online all seem to agree on one thing: nobody walked out of that theater the same person who walked in.
Wait, She Did What?
Here’s the premise, which sounds less like a documentary pitch and more like a dare: thirty-four days before she was sent to prison, the notorious Silicon Valley founder invited a skeptical film crew to document her every move, and what began as an intimate portrait of an enigmatic felon turned into a mind-bending, three-year journey.
Translation: the woman who convinced investors she’d built a machine that could diagnose cancer from a single drop of blood decided her next act would be letting Nathan Fielder — a man whose entire brand is making people confess things on camera they didn’t mean to — move in and film her life before she reported to federal prison.
If that premise alone doesn’t explain why the You Can See Everything first reactions exploded across social media within minutes of the Telluride screening, consider the runtime: a hefty 174 minutes, which is longer than most Avengers movies and, according to critics, somehow not long enough.
What the Critics Are Saying (Besides “What Did I Just Watch?”)
Let’s start with the reaction that basically became the unofficial tagline of the entire festival. Film journalist Matt Neglia tweeted a line that captured the mood of the room: he’d just seen one of the best documentaries he’d ever watched, calling it shocking, expansive, and revealing. That’s a pretty high bar to clear for a guy who presumably watches movies for a living and has, theoretically, seen everything.
Over at Variety, critic Owen Gleiberman described the film as a one-of-a-kind hybrid — part reality TV, part hangout movie, part full-blown psychodrama circus — that blurs reality, performance, deception, and mental illness until it brings viewers into the uncanny space where all of those things collide.
That is a lot of adjectives for one documentary, but then again, this is a documentary about a woman who built a billion-dollar company on the premise that a machine she never actually finished building could do the impossible, so maybe genre-blending chaos is simply the appropriate register.
IndieWire was similarly floored, noting that even after nearly three hours, the film somehow leaves audiences hungry and curious for more — which is either a testament to Fielder and Oppenheim’s filmmaking, or proof that watching Elizabeth Holmes is the cinematic equivalent of a car crash you cannot look away from.
Possibly both. The outlet also flagged the film’s “looming ambiguity,” praising how the directors let silence do the dirty work, giving subjects enough rope to tell on themselves without ever being asked a direct question.
Rotten Tomatoes’ roundup of the earliest notices leaned just as enthusiastic, with one critic admitting their jaw was on the floor and their breath had been taken away by the time the credits rolled, and declaring it potentially one of the most stunning documentaries ever made.
Meanwhile, The Emory Wheel took a more analytical angle, describing the project as best understood as an emotional tide that pulls the audience into the story’s truth and back out toward its possible deception. Very poetic for a movie about blood tests that didn’t work.
The Vibe at Telluride: Equal Parts Horror Movie and Group Therapy
According to World of Reel, the teaser alone had people rattled before the movie even started, describing it as unsettling, with strange lighting, extreme close-ups, prolonged eye contact, and a deliberately surreal presentation — essentially the visual language of a horror film, except the monster is a woman in black turtlenecks who already went to prison for this exact behavior.
The outlet summed up the overwhelming consensus simply: the early reactions were extremely positive, if deeply unsettled.
That “unsettled” quality seems to be the connective tissue running through nearly every You Can See Everything first reactions thread online. The Hollywood Reporter’s compilation of instant takes includes viewers calling it the most hysterical, shocking, insane documentary they’d ever witnessed, and others warning that the less you know going in, the better — which, ironically, is also the exact strategy Theranos investors should have used before writing checks.
Even Variety’s follow-up coverage noted that the film is sparking genuine Oscar-season chatter, with the publication confirming that the film’s central, surprising performance is eligible for Oscar recognition, though not through SAG — a sentence that will no doubt generate its own separate news cycle about whether a real person playing herself under federal scrutiny counts as “acting.”
So, Was It Good, or Just Deeply Weird?
Based on the avalanche of You Can See Everything first reactions, the honest answer seems to be: yes. Both. At the same time. Critics keep landing on words like “boundary-pushing,” “absurd,” and “shameless,” which, when you think about it, might also describe Theranos’s original pitch deck. Variety went so far as to call it a true parable for our time, which is either high praise or a very gentle way of saying America deserves this.
What’s clear is that the You Can See Everything first reactions have done exactly what A24 needed them to do: turn a secretive festival screening into the single biggest documentary conversation of the year, propel Nathan Fielder from cult-comedy figure to awards-season contender, and remind everyone that no matter how many times Elizabeth Holmes tries to disappear, the internet — much like her blood-testing machine allegedly could — insists it can see everything.
